The organ, with its majestic sound and intricate design, has long been revered as one of the most awe-inspiring instruments. But beneath that grandeur lies one of the most fascinating and intricate struggles in all of music—temperament. How do you tune an instrument capable of producing such complex tones in a way that balances its harmonies, dissonance, and versatility? For organ players and music enthusiasts alike, understanding temperament offers a glimpse into the mechanical imagination and the artistic struggle that shapes the music we hear.
This blog takes an adventurous dive into the history, science, and artistry behind musical temperament. It’s a topic that lets us explore the interplay of history and math. Let’s dive into an exploration of a topic that shaped much of Western music.
Azure Hills Music contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you when you purchase using one of these Amazon links. Read our disclaimer and privacy policy for more information.
What is Musical Temperament?
To the untrained ear, musical temperament might sound like something related to an artist’s mood, but it’s much more technical (though no less evocative). Temperament refers to the complicated process of tuning an instrument, particularly ones fixed like the organ, piano, or other keyboard instruments. Unlike string players or vocalists who can adjust their pitch on the fly, the organ is bound by physics and keys laid out centuries ago, immovable and unyielding.
The problem goes like this—if you try to tune an instrument so that one interval (like a fifth) is perfectly in tune, another interval (like a third) becomes far from perfect and dissonant. To resolve this, musicians and builders developed a kind of “compromise” tuning that balances intervals for a more universal sound. Over thousands of years, this balancing act has resulted in different “temperaments,” each one influencing how music sounds and feels.
The Search for the “Perfect” Temperament (And Why It Doesn’t Exist)
You might think, “There must be a way to create flawless harmony, right?” Well, here’s the kicker—physics says no. While some keys or intervals can sound pure on their own, achieving perfection across all keys on a fixed instrument is unattainable.
This imperfection creates a rich cultural narrative. Throughout history, humanity has found ways to turn these limitations into musical brilliance. Ancient cultures embraced dualities, accepting different temperaments as pathways to new creative expressions. History is dotted with tuning systems where some keys flourish while others “sour.” Think of it as choosing between a colorful garden where every flower blooms differently or a gray, uniform field. Both have their appeal, but neither is flawless.
Equal Temperament: The Ladder of Equality
Fast forward to today, and you’ll find that much of Western music exists in what’s known as equal temperament. It’s the most prevalent tuning method, where every key is “equally out of tune.” Sounds strange, but it works. Equal temperament divides the scale into twelve evenly spaced pitches, allowing composers to write freely in any key without experiencing the glaring disharmony of earlier systems. It’s a brilliant compromise, offering versatility at the cost of the “perfect” consonance in any key—a trade-off most accept readily.
To the modern ear, equal temperament feels “normal.” Yet seasoned musicians often pick up on what’s missing—the lively energy of earlier unequal temperaments, where certain keys shimmer with brightness while others brood with tension.
The Role of Temperament in Organ Music
Here’s where it gets fascinating (and challenging): the organ amplifies the imperfections of temperament. Unlike plucked or struck keyboard instruments like the harpsichord or piano—whose sound fades over time—the organ produces sustained tones. Those tones linger, giving your ear more time to recognize when something feels slightly “off.” Add to that the organ’s multidimensional harmonics, built with off-unison pitches and combinations of stops, and you’ve got a recipe for exposing every nuance (or flaw) in temperament.
But it’s precisely this sensitivity that makes the organ a playground for musical temperaments. Earlier tunings like meantone offered luminous, clear chords in select keys—perfect for the music of their era. However, this also meant that “wolf tones” (intensely dissonant intervals) lurked in certain key signatures, deterring composers from exploring them.
A Journey Through Temperament History
The Rise of Unequal Temperaments
Historically, composers explored and adapted to the tuning systems of their time. For centuries, meantone temperament was the go-to for its ability to produce clean thirds. However, it restricted composers to specific harmonies, limiting musical exploration. Unequal temperaments, like Werckmeister or Vallotti, opened a few more doors, allowing for greater tonal flexibility while still preserving the uniqueness of individual keys.
Equal Temperament Takes Over
By the 18th century, as composers like Bach began demanding more tonal possibilities, the movement toward equal temperament gained momentum. This system made all keys equally usable, paving the way for more ambitious compositions in complexity and key exploration. While this shift expanded the musical language, it also muted the distinctive personalities of individual keys.
Temperament and Authenticity in Organ Performance
Modern organists face a dilemma when interpreting historical works—should they stick to the temperaments of the composer’s time or lean on equal temperament for a more consistent performance? Playing Bach’s The Well-Tempered Clavier or Pachelbel’s works on equal temperament is a different experience than hearing them on historic tunings; the dissonances, consonance, and emotional weight change completely.
On the flip side, asking composers like Brahms or Duruflé to conform to historical tunings does them a disservice. Their works were designed for equal temperaments and the freedom those tunings afforded.
Evolving Preferences and the Road Ahead
Today, the organ world is seeing a resurgence of interest in historic temperaments. Builders now craft instruments tuned in Vallotti, Werckmeister, Kellner, and even more obscure systems to replicate the sounds composers originally envisioned. Some adventurous musicians seek well-tempered systems where keys range from tart to sweet, providing a diverse “flavor palette” for performances.
That said, equal temperament remains the foundation of modern Western keyboard music. It’s a familiar, reliable ladder where every rung is evenly spaced. New technologies, like digital and hybrid pipe organs, offer opportunities to experiment with quarter-tone systems and layered temperaments, hinting at what the future may hold.
Why Temperament Matters
Whether you’re an organist selecting a tuning system, a builder shaping an instrument’s voice, or an enthusiast listening to a recital, temperament affects how you perceive the music. It’s the subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) flavoring that shapes the emotional resonance of every chord and interval. Understanding it is like unlocking a deeper appreciation for the artistry behind not only the organ but music itself.
Final Thoughts: Exploring the World of Temperament
The world of musical temperament is as rich and varied as music itself. From the luminous perfection of meantone chords to the universal accessibility of equal temperament, every tuning system reflects a unique balance of science, artistry, and compromise.
For those eager to explore further, we encourage you to experience the difference yourself. Visit historic organs tuned in traditional temperaments, or try an experimental setup on a digital organ. Every variation adds a new layer of fascination to an already extraordinary instrument.
Choosing a temperament is, at its core, an act of artistic expression. Perhaps the real question isn’t which temperament is “best,” but which opens the most creative doors for your playing and listening experience.
Thanks for visiting this page.